Wrote the following on Dr. James White’s youtube:
Thank you very much, James.
First I would like to say that Robert Spencer, Sam Shamoun, David Wood and Christian Prince are ignorant and pompous fools.
My apologies for saying this but this is what I concluded about those men. What many anti-Islam polemicists do not really know is that Hadith is simply a collection of tales and narrations and it is not a scripture of Islam.
Also, Hadith is not obligatory on Muslims. Qur’aan is the only Scripture of Islam and Hadith should be scrutinised under the light and shade of Qur’aan. If a Hadith does not stand correct under the scrutiny of Qur’aan, it has to be rejected and discarded.
All the scholars have classified Hadith as right, correct, authentic, not reliable, incorrect, untrustworthy, defective, no chain of narrators, etc. If every Hadith were true, they would not have classified so. Right?
Also, many ahaadith (plural of hadith) came through Israeliyaat ( narrations from pagans, Christians and Jews) and many entered the books.
Please note that there is no Hadith collection done by Arabs. Bukhari, Dawood, Muslim, Ibne Ma’aja, Tabari and others were all tale-collectors from Central Asia. None of them was an Arab.
Those men came two hundred plus years after the Prophet had passed away and their collections were not even available in public domain for another few hundred years.
It is very easy to demolish and debunk ahaadith under the scrutiny of Qur’aan. I think polemicists like David Wood, Robert Spencer, Sam Shamoun, Christian Prince and Robert Morey read Hadith more than Muslims, who do not even read it and do not keep any collections at home.