In the Quran, Allah declares that various law-breakers were transformed into apes and pigs. Since Muhammad was known for plagiarizing stories from Jews and Christians, we may wonder where Muhammad heard fables about Allah miraculously disfiguring people. In “Shabir Ally, the Quran, and the Village of the Apes and Swine: Part 1” (- YouTube), Anthony Rogers searched for the origin of this story. In Part 2, Anthony addresses Shabir Ally’s attempts to interpret the story figuratively.
How was this video never recommended for me😱, its content is money.
Quran is the most creepy Japanese anime book. Change my mind
allah is supposed to be perfect, at least in communicating with his own creation (us) there should be zero confusion to his words like it is shown here.
allah is so dumb
Hey, Anthony, should Christians eat pork? I only ask because I was born in Memphis, TN, and my birthplace is known for REALLY GOOD BBQ pork.
I love how you treat Islam’s sources as fairy tales, yet there are even stories in the bible that are also fantastical. These are just some of my favorite…
Genesis 3: A talking snake.
Genesis 6-8: The story of a world wide flood, or rather, the bit about a boat being able to hold 2-7 of every kind of animal from all across the world.
Numbers 22 : A talking Donkey.
The Gospel According to St. Matthew 27 51-53: A mass resurrection of saints, all of which had been dead for years.
can Shabbir ally said where the sun setting
by what shabir aly says you can go down a wormhole trying to prove yourself right, when IT IS CLEAR THAT THE CHANGES WERE LITERATE, THE PEOPLE ACCORDING TO ALLAH CHANGED. THIS IS WHAT ALL MAJOR MUSLIM SCHOLARS ADMIT. ALLAH NEVER SPEAKS FIGURATIVELY IN THE QURAN.
I would love to see the day Mr Aly admits that the quran does contradict and contain mistakes.
it really hurts being born and brought up as a muslim, then realizing such silly nonsense, all respect to Mr David Wood for starting this channel and revealing the truth to those who think with an open mind and are knowledgeable.
I BBQ Pork when ever I can, in hope of the smell getting to a Muslim.
How is Allah turning people into apes and swine more ridiculous than God making Balaam’s donkey speak? I am a Christian and I believe the Koran is fiction, but I don’t understand why your argument couldn’t just be turned on that passage in Numbers. I understand that you are saying Muhammad ripped his story off the Jewish story, but suppose for example there is a Persian fable where an animal is given the ability to speak. Couldn’t your same argument be used against the Bible in those circumstances?
ha ha ha…
Hey, on an unrelated topic, is David Wood by chance related to the American artist Grant Wood? They share the same last name and look very similar.
i saw an ad for ramadan before i watched this video. i am rathet pleased with the irony
“We are just like you, my friend.”
“We just want to live in peace, my friend.”
“We are a good people, my friend.”
“There are only a very few bad Muslims, my friend.”
“Believe me, my friend, Trust me, my friend.”
“Allah Akbar!”…”B O O M”!!!
“Ha! Ha! Ha! Stupid Infidels!”
THIS is what Islam does. Simple enough?
Christians argue about the application of their text, and Muslims argue about the basic meaning.